How Do You Know?

On physics, metaphysics, and philosophy at UVA

The other day, I diagnosed a patient with depression and wrote her a script for Lexapro.

How does it work? she asked.

It increases serotonin, I said.

And how does serotonin improve my mood?

Well, it binds to receptors in the brain.

Oh. Cool. Where?

So, the amygdala, the hippocampus, and the prefrontal cortex.

And how does that improve my mood?

It just does, I said. It’s related. Higher levels of serotonin are associated with improved mood.

Silence. This was going nowhere fast.

Look, I said. As to the exact chain of cause and effect, I’ll admit we don’t understand much about that. Let’s just see if it works for you….

When I was a young medical student I remember observing a doctor with a patient who asked her one too many questions. Just take the pill! the doctor finally exclaimed, rolling her eyes.

I’ll never be like that, I said to myself at the time. And, in fact, I am pleased to report that I controlled myself and did not roll my eyes.

And, to be honest, my patient was right. Most of what we think we know in medicine is more mnemonic than truth.

We notice a possible cause and effect. Is it reproducible? If so, we call it evidence-based. If not, we call it chance. How it works matters less than if it works.

Last month, Rachel and I visited our son, Ariel, who is a sophomore at the University of Virginia. It was Parents Weekend and, to my great delight, he invited me to sit in on his Philosophy of Religion class review session.

He introduced me to the grad student teaching the session, who was named Dakota, same as our dog. I somehow resisted remarking on this amazing coincidence, much to Ariel’s relief.

Dakota walked the class through a discussion of determinism and free will. Are they compatible or incompatible? In a universe ruled by physics – which includes our brains – is everything predetermined by causal chains, or is there room for free choice?

In the end, everyone agreed that there is no free will. At least, not according to the laws of physics. And, by the way, in case you’re interested, that’s true even for quantum physics, where things occur by chance.

I looked around the room. None of the students seemed the least bit perturbed. And not because they weren’t paying attention. In fact, I was impressed by the diligent note-taking. Maybe it was Adderall or the upcoming test – maybe it was both.

Meanwhile, I was perturbed. After all, it seems to me that without free will, our world becomes unrecognizable. Without free will how do you get to morality? Freedom? Good and evil? How do you get to love?

If there is no free will – if all of our thoughts and actions unfold as predictably as a chemical reaction – then what’s the difference between a human being and ChatGPT? And if there is no difference, then how is taking a human life any worse than unplugging a machine?

I chose not to share all this with Ariel. I didn’t want him to regret inviting me to class. I just wanted to help him pass the test – which, I’m proud to say, he did – with flying colors.

As for me, I consoled myself with the following three thoughts.

One, perhaps the exact mechanism doesn’t matter for free will any more than it does for serotonin. They work, therefore they are.

Two, granted that a world of metaphysics can’t emerge from the world of physics, but what about the other way around? Maybe a world of physics can emerge from the world of metaphysics. Like the chicken and the egg. Which came first, God or the universe?

I ran the idea by Peter, my friend from medical school, who also happens to be a philosophy professor. If I understood him correctly, the argument is sound (or at least, begrudgingly, not unsound).

Three, worst case scenario, let’s say we view freedom, love, and goodness are mere illusions that don’t truly exist – well, what of it? Maybe that’s OK – as long as we preserve the existence of Lexapro.

Dr. Bertie Bregman
Dr. Bertie Bregman
Full Stack Family Medicine is a newsletter about what it’s really like to practice medicine and run a medical practice in New York City.
This blog will be a mix of stories, advice and discussion – topics will diverge widely, but they will all share a point of view!